The web-site is now in readonly mode. Login and registration are disabled. (28 June 2019)

What works best and when : Elluminate or Flashmeeting? Or none of the above?

What has your experience been of using Elluminate or Flashmeetings? How do they compare? What has...

Cloud created by:

Margaret Byrne
5 April 2010

What has your experience been of using Elluminate or Flashmeetings? How do they compare? What has worked best for you as a learner or teacher? When is it best to use Elluminate or a Flashmeeting. Do you think either Elluminate or Flashmeetings are effective synchronous online tools? Or have they not worked for you?

Please feel free to add links and references and join in the debate.

Extra content

I have used FM and Elly quite a bit and wjilts I agree there are horses for courses, I do think that FM allows deeper discussion for a Masters course - and you don't have to worry about note taking! Provded of course it is automatically recorded.  Here is a comparison I put together for debate!

 

Flashmeeting

Elluminate

Similar tool features

Synchronicity, chatbox, voice, whiteboard annotation, upload presentations, send URL/webtour, voting, possible bandwidth/accessibility limitation.

Designed pedagogy

Learner-centric.  No hierarchy

Teacher-centric.  Needs moderator to operate meeting

Interrupt

Single voice  – ability to interrupt

Single voice - multiple if moderator allows

Queuing

Automatic

Needs moderator management

Video

Simultaneous video of each participant

Moderator video

Additional tool features

None

Polling, quizzes etc

User interface

Easy/intuitive

Needs training

Breakout rooms

None

Need to set up slides in advance for each room – no automatic saving of annotated whiteboards in rooms.  Participants moved by moderator.

Application sharing

N/A

Works well

Asynchronicity

Automatic archiving

No automatic archiving.  Needs action by moderator and cannot save breakout room conversation.

Barbara
17:52 on 10 April 2010

Embedded Content

Contribute