The web-site is now in readonly mode. Login and registration are disabled. (28 June 2019)

Developing reflective practice in relation to source critique and evaluation in a level 1 course in Art/Humanities

Cloud created by:

eva parisinou
1 April 2015

Narrator

Learning how to approach and to make sense of primary materials is one of the key skills to which introductory courses in Arts/Humanities aim for their students to acquire. Many students find it challenging, at least initially, to develop a critical distance to what they read or see, let alone beginning to use primary evidence in a reflective way in their assignments. My role is to a) facilitate students’ engagement with the existing resources which already belong to the Learning Design of the course that I teach, and b) to further assist them with practicing the skills of critical approach and evaluation of texts and images from their course materials.

 Situation

This is an example of a way how I try to facilitate students' engagement with the approach and analysis of texts and images, with a special concern for students who seem to be encountering difficulties/be unfamiliar with developing a critical distance from the sources they are required to evaluate. Students who face such difficulties may express a judgemental attitudes towards the sources or images they are to comment on and evaluate, likes or dislikes, and may sometimes simply ‘ignore’ the primary material- or largely doing so- preferring to base their discussion on secondary literature instead. Students sometimes choose to comment on aspects of the sources selectively when they feel they could apply something of what they had read and understood in the course resources and which ‘fits’ the sources they have to approach. There can also be a tendency to ‘by-pass’ or not to use concepts and terms which students have not understood  in order to turn them into a usable resource that they could transfer onto their attempts at source critique and evaluation.

Task

Points (a) and (b) as outlined above under ‘narrator’.

Actions

1. Creating a ‘safe’ space usually in a face-to-face and/or a telephone tutorial inviting them to reflect on their own attitudes towards the sources, and the way they understand and go about source critique and evaluation.

2. Reflecting back to them some of the points they raised. Examples of such comments are given above under ‘situation’.

3. Inviting them to observe patterns in their attitudes of thinking about/responding to sources which may or may not be of a genre that they are used to dealing with in their everyday and/or professional life.

4. Sometimes I invite them to offer examples of primary sources in the area where they live and work, and we draw links between familiarity with/being used to a concept and the ‘ease’ or willingness to work with it.

5. Once we get these ‘psychological’ aspects of learning worked out, to some extent, we then begin to engage with the sources afresh, often with the aid of other group members who have more familiarity and willingness with those type of sources. And that would eventually lead us to move onto the specific advice offered in the course materials.

 Reflections

It does not always work but it has worked for a good number of students who managed to see the purpose of engaging with the sources rather than sticking with the views of ‘experts’/teachers by mainly/only engaging with the secondary literature.

It has enabled students to reflect on their own patterns of learning, and this has on occasion been mentioned by them in their reflective reviews which forms part of the assessment requirements in the course.

This part of leaning design usually relates to what I do with students in the first half of the course – in the very beginning- and which I then I follow up on in my feedback on later assignments as well where relevant. It is not for everyone but can help a good number of students to engage with disciplines and views (through text or image) which may be unfamiliar and therefore inaccessible territory to them.

Extra content

Embedded Content

added by eva parisinou

Contribute

eva parisinou
10:08am 1 April 2015


This is just a brief draft giving an idea of a practice rather than anything close to a formal prsentation of a leanring design. Some ideas and some sharing of practice.

Eva

Catherine Lee
1:14pm 8 April 2015 (Edited 1:14pm 8 April 2015)


Hi Eva,

No surprise that I found your narrative very interesting :-)

I don't think you are making implcit assumtions; your identification of the learning problem is based on past and present experience. 

You make few claims about the effects of the design, merely that it works for some students; likewise, your conclusions. 

What I find positive about your design is that it is very learner-centred, accepting each student's individual starting point and supporting them in making adjustments to their own understanding. 

Thanks -you've given me food for thought!

b/w

Catherine

eva parisinou
7:42am 15 April 2015


Catherine,

sorry for the delayed response; glad you found something to think about from this plan. and grateful for the comments too!

These were just rough thoughts rather than anything that was ironed out for presentation and indeed I spotted glitches in the grammar and presentation shortly after I submitted it. Time is pressuring on..

The major point that I am trying to make is that, as you spotted too, learning is a process that invlolves making something 'your own' by somehow fitting it into your wider spectrum of knolwedge and emotive states (towards the topic/wider area of disciplie and what it represents to you)..that's what I meant by 'psychological' aspects. This may involve having to reflect on what you already know, what you have experienced, how you felt about it (fears/joys/anxieties towards topics/people/systems who taught them) and to find a place for it. This may take different lengths of time and effort for everyone, and I find this fascinating as a topic in its own right..

Eva

Contribute to the discussion

Please log in to post a comment. Register here if you haven't signed up yet.